This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.

Insights & Events

| 3 minute read

Could the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 regulate responsible landlords out of the market?

For many “accidental” landlords, letting a former home was never intended to become a business. Keeping a flat as a source of additional income, or to help fund retirement, can seem a straightforward decision. Yet managing even one rental property in England brings a complex mix of costs, responsibilities and regulatory requirements and these have been extended further by the terms of the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 (“the Act”).

The stronger protections for tenants introduced by the Act are welcome. The question is how the cumulative demands of letting affect smaller landlords and whether those pressures could ultimately influence the supply of homes available to rent.

Growing responsibilities for smaller landlords

For landlords facing higher mortgage costs, the financial balance may already feel less comfortable than when they first decided to let. The increase in income tax on rental income scheduled for April 2027 adds yet another consideration. With the government appearing to abandon plans for the much discussed increases in CGT, at least for the time being, is now the time for reluctant landlords to leave the market?

Alongside those financial pressures, the Act is changing the regulatory landscape in England. The government’s implementation roadmap provides for the phased introduction of the private rented sector database from late 2026. Registration requirements, associated fees and penalties for non-compliance represent a further layer of administration for landlords.

These measures form part of a wider effort to improve standards and accountability which is of course in the interests of all. The intention appears to be to police landlords who deliberately disregard their obligations which again is welcomed by all. However, the impact on an individual letting a former home who must also navigate the requirements that apply to their property, is burdensome and could make letting a less attractive prospect.

Shared occupation: an additional compliance concern

Separate from the Act’s new registration framework, shared occupation raises its own compliance questions. Sharing a home can help tenants spread housing costs, but the number of occupiers and their household arrangements can also affect a landlord’s responsibilities.

A property may be a house in multiple occupation (“HMO”) where as few as three people from more than one household share facilities such as a kitchen or bathroom. Whether it requires a licence depends on the circumstances and the applicable local scheme; smaller shared properties can fall within additional licensing requirements.

These protections are important for the safety and suitability of shared accommodation. However, failing to obtain a required licence can expose a landlord to enforcement action and substantial financial penalties. The distinction between deliberate non-compliance and misunderstanding an obligation matter to the discussion, but an accidental landlord should not assume that a small portfolio places them outside the licensing regime.

A different framework for recovering possession

The abolition of section 21 “no-fault” eviction for private assured tenancies in England from 1 May 2026 also changes the context in which landlords manage their properties. It does not remove every route to possession but landlords must instead establish an applicable statutory ground and follow the relevant procedure.

A breach of a tenancy agreement (for example sharing occupation), which would amount to a discretionary ground, does not necessarily entitle a landlord to an outright possession order. In fact, most practitioners would tell you that it almost never does and the best a landlord can hope for is a suspended order and that assumes that the tenancy agreement even includes a prohibition against sharing occupation!

What could this mean for the rental market?

For smaller landlords, the concern is the cumulative effect of these pressures rather than any single requirement on its own. If the cost and complexity of letting prompt some to sell, the potential consequences include fewer homes available to rent and greater concentration of ownership among those able to remain in the sector.

Those outcomes are risks, not certainties. Any effect on rental supply or rents will depend on wider market conditions and what happens to properties when landlords leave. Even so, they are relevant to the broader question of how stronger tenant protections can sit alongside a sustainable rental market.

Protecting tenants and retaining responsible landlords should not be competing objectives. The challenge is to raise standards without making the cumulative demands of compliance a reason for smaller landlords to leave and, in doing so, risk reducing choice for the tenants the Act is intended to protect.

Sign up to receive the latest insights from Edwin Coe. Subscribe now!

Tags

property disputes, insights