This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.

Insights & Events

| 5 minute read

AI tax advice: the hidden cost of an unchecked answer

An AI chatbot can answer a tax question in seconds, without the upfront cost of a professional consultation. But if you use that answer to complete your return, the saving can come at a price. 

HMRC can already require taxpayers to provide digital records where these are needed to check that the right amount of tax has been paid.

The government’s new proposals would extend those powers by broadening the type of digital information HMRC can access. This could include records held within, or generated through, AI chatbots.

Third parties, including software providers, could also be required to hand over tax-related information they hold about users.

HMRC’s proposed changes to its digital information powers put the process behind tax figures into sharper focus. Relevant AI prompts and responses could form part of the information sought in a tax check. You need to be able to explain not just what the AI tool told you, but what you did to check the answer and why you relied on it.

AI answers do not bring the same assurance as professional advice

There is a difference between using AI to explore a tax question and relying on its analysis when completing your return. Once an answer informs the position you submit, the checks behind it matter.

An answer can look comprehensive while missing a decisive fact, applying the wrong tax year or relying on a source that does not support the conclusion. 

Professional advice provides a different basis for reliance. If you give a competent adviser full and accurate facts and reasonably rely on their advice, you can be protected from a careless inaccuracy penalty even if the advice proves wrong. No matter what method you use, your own conduct still matters: you must check what you reasonably can and address obvious errors.

An AI generated response does not, by itself, give you the same basis for demonstrating informed reliance on a competent professional adviser. If HMRC challenges your tax treatment, saying that AI supplied the analysis does not establish that you took reasonable care. You need to show what you checked and why the position you adopted was reasonable.

The Test for Carelessness

HMRC’s disagreement with your tax position does not automatically make you careless. The legal test is whether the inaccuracy resulted from a failure to take reasonable care. That depends on your abilities, circumstances and the complexity of the issue. Professional advice does not guarantee protection from a penalty, and using AI does not automatically make you careless.

Where HMRC argue that a tax loss has been caused by carelessness, they can extend the ordinary assessment limit from four years to six years after the end of the relevant tax year. Longer limits apply in other circumstances, including deliberate behaviour, failure to notify and certain offshore matters. HMRC must establish the conditions for the extension, including the link between the carelessness and the tax loss. This means that reliance on AI without the proper checks could lead to penalties and lengthier enquiries.

HMRC’s focus extends to the information behind the answer

HMRC already has powers to request information and documents reasonably required to check your tax position. The proposed digital information changes would broaden the framework for examining how relevant information is produced and obtaining technical assistance. They do not amount to an unrestricted right to inspect your AI account.

If AI has materially informed your return, the relevant evidence extends beyond the final answer. The facts you supplied, the assumptions made, the sources checked and any corrections help explain how you reached the position submitted. A prompt containing an incomplete description of a transaction can be as significant as the response it generated.

AI chat histories contain more than tax calculations

AI conversations can contain more than the tax question itself. They can include personal details, commercially sensitive material and information about family members, employees, clients or counterparties. A request relating to a tax calculation can therefore involve records containing information beyond the calculation.

Context matters too. A hypothetical question, an abandoned suggestion or an inaccurate AI generated statement should not be mistaken for a fact about your affairs or the position you ultimately adopted. Keep the AI’s suggestions distinguishable from verified facts and the final advice or calculation.

HMRC’s requests remain subject to the requirement that information be reasonably required and to the applicable statutory safeguards. Confidentiality does not provide a blanket exemption, but a tax check does not make every conversation relevant. If a request captures unrelated material, review its scope and raise the issue with HMRC before supplying information.

Legal professional privilege is a separate protection. Qualifying privileged material remains protected, but tax advice from an accountant does not become legally privileged simply because it concerns tax law. Do not assume that a chatbot conversation is privileged. Before putting privileged advice into an AI service, consider confidentiality and how the service handles the information.

Keep a proportionate record

You must keep the records needed to support a correct and complete return. This is not new. But there is no general AI-specific rule requiring you to retain every prompt and response. If AI materially influences a tax decision, however, a proportionate record helps you explain both the calculation and the care you took.

Alongside your underlying tax records, consider retaining:

  1. The date of the exchange, the AI tool and model or version used, where available, and the relevant tax and tax year.
  2. The relevant prompts, factual inputs and material responses you relied on, including any attachments or source documents that affected the answer.
  3. The legislation, guidance and other sources you checked, with the relevant version or date recorded.
  4. The calculations, corrections and professional advice that confirmed or changed the AI analysis.
  5. A concise explanation of the final decision, who reviewed it and how it connects to the figures or treatment in your return.

These are practical recommendations, not a requirement to preserve every draft or unrelated conversation indefinitely. Follow the relevant tax record retention rules and keep personal data only for as long as it is needed for a justified purpose. If a prompt or output is itself a supporting tax record, retain it accordingly. If you receive an information notice or become subject to an enquiry, check the applicable preservation obligations before deleting relevant material.

Do not assume that the platform will retain your exchanges or let you export the records you need. Check its terms and settings for retention, model training, access and export.

Advisers need to understand their clients’ AI use

Advisers should be asking clients whether AI has influenced their tax analysis and obtain the relevant exchanges early. They should establish which facts were supplied, which conclusions were relied on and which checks were undertaken, then address unsupported assumptions before they reach the return, and document their review.

A low-cost answer is not always a low-cost outcome

The cost of AI tax advice is not limited to the price of using the tool. You also need to account for the time spent checking its analysis, obtaining professional advice where needed and keeping records of the position adopted. If HMRC opens an enquiry, explaining and defending that position can add further time and expense - outweighing the initial saving on advice. AI can be a useful starting point, but a low-cost answer is not always a low-cost outcome.

Use AI to explore the issue, verify the analysis before relying on it, and keep a proportionate record of the checks and advice supporting your return. Responsibility for taking reasonable care remains with you, whatever tool you use.

 

Sign up to receive the latest insights from Edwin Coe. Subscribe now!

Tags

tax disputes, tax risk reviews and stress testing, tax, tax compliance, private client, corporate, insights