This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.

Insights & Events

| 6 minute read

Almacantar -V- De Valk; The Court of Appeal Widens the Reach of the Building Safety Act

Just when we think we understand the boundaries of the Building Safety Act 2022, another judgment arrives to remind us that the legislation is far from settled.

The latest is  Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Ltd and another v De Valk and others [2026] EWCA Civ 1466, handed down by the Court of Appeal on 17 November 2026.

The dispute concerned £12 million of proposed repairs to the façade of London’s Centre Point House. The question was whether qualifying leaseholders could be required to contribute towards the cost. 

The Court’s answer was no.

More importantly, it confirmed that  the protection against costs for cladding remediation under paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 can apply even where the underlying defect is not a statutory ‘relevant defect’, including where the underlying defect arose from construction completed before the 30-year relevant period began.

I have long been concerned that our understanding of what falls within the Building Safety Act (BSA) would continue to change as the courts examined its provisions. This decision reinforces that concern. For conveyancers, it also raises an important question: how do we protect clients today against liabilities whose legal position may not become clear for years?

A £12 million problem at Centre Point

Centre Point House forms part of the famous 1960s development near Tottenham Court Road. It contains 36 flats above commercial premises.  Its design was experimental, but its façade system proved inherently defective.

The building incorporated an unusual timber-framed façade system whose construction permitted water ingress. Over time, the timber deteriorated and rotted. The proposed solution involved installing a new steel curtain wall system fixed to the building’s concrete structure. The estimated cost exceeded £12 million, including VAT and professional fees.

The freeholders applied to the First-tier Tribunal for a determination of whether service charges would be payable for the proposed scheme and, if so, by whom.

The First-tier Tribunal found that the works fell within the landlords’ repairing obligations and would ordinarily have been recoverable through the service charge. However, it decided that paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the BSA prevented recovery from qualifying leaseholders.

The Upper Tribunal upheld that decision. The freeholders then appealed to the Court of Appeal, which confirmed that the First-tier Tribunal had been correct and dismissed the appeal.

When is a relevant defect not relevant?

The central argument concerned the statutory definition of a ‘relevant defect’.

Under section 120 of the BSA, a relevant defect must arise from specified works and cause a building safety risk. In the case of original construction or conversion works, those works must have been completed in the 30-year period ending on 28 June 2022, and causing a building safety risk involving fire spread or collapse.

Centre Point House was constructed in the 1960s. Its original defective façade fell outside that period.

The freeholders argued that paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 should therefore not apply. There was, however, a difficulty with that argument. The wording.

Paragraph 8 provides that no service charge is payable under a qualifying lease in respect of cladding remediation. Unlike several neighbouring provisions, it makes no express reference to relevant defects. The Court considered that omission significant.

Parliament had used the expression elsewhere in Schedule 8 but had not included it in paragraph 8. The Court declined to introduce a restriction which Parliament had not written into the legislation.

The Court has not expanded the definition of a relevant defect. It has confirmed that a significant statutory protection operates independently of that definition.

Consequently, the original age of a defect does not necessarily prevent paragraph 8 from applying. 

The Court also rejected the argument that unsafe cladding must be combustible or contribute to the spread of fire. At paragraph 58, Newey and Fancourt LJJ explained that ‘unsafe’ bears its ordinary meaning of ‘involving danger’ and is not restricted to fire risks. That does not mean every leaking façade or defective window engages the legislation. The works must still satisfy the statutory definition of cladding remediation. Indeed, the Court expressly left open whether a cladding system constituting the whole of an external wall system could fall within paragraph 8(2).

There will undoubtedly be further arguments about precisely where those boundaries lie.

The problem with moving boundaries

One observation from the judgment particularly caught my attention. At paragraph 45, the Court acknowledged that the BSA uses a ‘bright lines’ approach capable of producing seemingly arbitrary or anomalous results. The legislation can produce dramatically different financial consequences depending on the nature and timing of the defect, the landlord’s position and whether the lease is a qualifying lease.

At Centre Point House, the freeholders were obliged to undertake repairs but could not recover the proposed costs from the qualifying leaseholders. Other leaseholders without qualifying leases remained potentially liable under their leases. When the repair bill exceeds £12 million, these distinctions are hardly academic. 

However, there is a wider point. Our understanding of how the BSA applies today may not be the same in five years.

The statutory wording has not changed because of Almacantar. What has changed is our authoritative understanding of its application.

As further cases reach the courts, some circumstances previously thought to fall outside particular protections may prove to be covered. Equally, future judgments may establish limits which had not previously been appreciated. That is the nature of developing case law.

It is also what makes this legislation particularly challenging for property transactions. A legal assessment made today must sometimes rely on statutory boundaries which have not yet been fully tested.

We cannot know every issue the courts will be asked to resolve tomorrow.

Why I insist on getting the certificates

The leaseholder deed of certificate and the landlord’s certificate are often considered only when a building safety issue has already been identified. That is understandable, but it misses an important point.

These documents may become important long after the transaction in which they could most easily have been obtained.

A building may have no identified defects today. A problem could emerge shortly after completion or many years later. The courts may also clarify that a statutory protection applies in circumstances previously thought to fall outside the regime.

Establishing whether a lease qualifies for that protection may then depend on the former leaseholder’s position on 14 February 2022, including what properties they owned and whether the flat was their principal home.

The leaseholder deed of certificate records the information relied on to establish qualifying lease status and determine the application of the leaseholder protections. Depending on the circumstances, the supporting evidence may include historical ownership details, proof of occupation, the last pre-February 2022 sale price and shared ownership information.

If that evidence is not collected during the sale, retrieving it later may be difficult. The former leaseholder may have moved abroad or may no longer be willing or able to assist. Years later, the current owner could be left trying to reconstruct property ownership and occupation arrangements from February 2022 and locate records which no longer exist.

This is why I take a conservative approach. Where there is a reasonable possibility that the regime applies, I favour obtaining the leaseholder deed of certificate and supporting evidence during the transaction, together with any landlord’s certificate issued for the lease. That remains my approach even where the present position is not entirely clear. The cost of obtaining and retaining the evidence now is modest compared with the potential difficulty of reconstructing it after a defect or liability has emerged.

Nor is the leaseholder deed particularly onerous. Where the relevant HM Land Registry documents are available, most leaseholders should be able to complete it in around 10 to 15 minutes. Set against the other forms routinely required when selling a flat, that is not a significant additional administrative burden.

Government guidance expressly envisages the leaseholder deed being passed to future owners through the conveyancing process.

We do not know how the courts will define every boundary of the regime in future. The time to collect the historical evidence is when it is readily available, not when a future dispute has made it indispensable.

What does this mean for conveyancing?

Almacantar v De Valk provides welcome clarification of the Building Safety Act.

But it also demonstrates why I have been reluctant to treat our present understanding of its scope as the final word. The legislation is still relatively young. Its practical application continues to develop through litigation, and further decisions may clarify both the reach and limits of its protections.

That uncertainty is not a reason to stop transactions. It is a reason to prepare properly.

For our Property team, the approach remains practical: understand the building, establish the statutory position, obtain the correct documentation and preserve the evidence.

Most clients are not interested in becoming involved in arguments about statutory interpretation. They want to buy, sell or manage their property without an unexpected financial liability appearing years later.

A conveyancer cannot predict every future judgment. But we can make sure that the evidence needed to deal with tomorrow’s questions is not unnecessarily lost today.

The law may continue to develop. The evidence should already be in the file.

How Edwin Coe can help

Edwin Coe’s Property team advises on residential and mixed-use property transactions, freehold investments and complex leasehold matters, including properties affected by the Building Safety Act 2022.

For advice concerning property transactions, leaseholder protections, building safety documentation or remediation liabilities, please contact Charlie Davidson, Senior Associate in our Property team.

This article reflects the legal position in England as at 20 November 2026 and is intended for general information only. It does not constitute legal advice. The application of the Building Safety Act 2022 depends on the circumstances of the individual building, lease and proposed works.

Case: Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Ltd v De Valk [2026] EWCA Civ 1466.

We agree. First, and crucially, paragraph 8 is not stated to apply only in relation to "relevant defects". Unlike paragraphs 2-7 and 9, paragraph 8 does not mention them. The contrast tends to confirm that paragraph 8 was not meant to be limited to "relevant defects".

Sign up to receive the latest insights from Edwin Coe. Subscribe now!

Tags

residential property, real estate, property disputes, property, insights